Riverside Logistics

by

When should I consider using a different mode for my domestic freight?

First, let’s go over what the domestic modes of transportation are. In commercial transportation there are 6 modes of note: Truck, Rail, Water, Air, Pipeline, and Intermodal. In this article we will be discussing all of them except pipeline.

Domestic Water and Rail transport usually revolve around bulk commodity movements.

Water/Barge traffic moves commodities like sand, coal, paper, lumber, stone, chemicals, and ash. Rail does too. Rail moves a significant amount of coal and other mined products. Most railcar fleets consist of flatcars, hopper and tanker cars used for handling chemicals, wood, stone, coal and mined product, dimensional lumber, and timber. Very little rail traffic is in boxcars. In fact, the railroads are not really building or leasing any new boxcars for their fleets. They have determined that the money is to be made in bulk commodities, particularly coal. Domestic water traffic handles (mostly) bulk commodities as well. Both Rail and Barge traffic are usually used when the commodities being handled are low in value and in bulk form. Tradeoffs between water and rail depend a lot on access to each mode, and whether time in transit is a concern. In addition, seasonal factors can come into play.

Water

Domestic water traffic shuts down when their bodies of water freeze or flood. There is uncertainty in delivery times attached to the water mode at certain times of the year, primarily during winter and spring. These can be disruptive to travel schedules. So, if consistency of delivery throughout the year is a concern, then waterborne traffic will be problematic during certain times of the year. Water has some inherent advantages over other modes. It can handle significant weight with little change in operating cost. The added cost of another barge in the tow is minimal. Water can charge extremely low unit costs for transportation. Their costs per ton mile as a unit of measure are the lowest across the modes (except pipeline, which we won’t discuss here). If you have access to water transport and produce a bulk commodity, such as those listed above, then it is a viable form of transport and should receive consideration. If you would have to truck product to the on-load and off-load sites to use water transport, then those costs must be factored into the equation, as does the cost of managing multi-modal interchanges to get product from A to B.

Rail

Rail on the other hand, doesn’t have a seasonality issue like water. It does have an access issue, in that, without railroad spurs at your Distribution Center (DC) or your manufacturing site, you would have to move product to and from the rail siding by truck. That also holds true for the delivery sites as well. Once again, a potential added cost that needs to factor into the equation. Rail moves, steel wheels on steel track, is much more cost effective than trucking when you consider the length of haul. The rule-of-thumb is over 1000 miles rail is much more effective than truck. One rail car can usually haul as much product as 4 trucks. One train can usually carry the equivalent of 400 trucks. Rail is the cheaper alternative on land versus trucking. However, trucking can pickup anywhere and deliver anywhere. Rail cannot. Trucking can also move product faster than rail. For example, a typical coast to coast shipment will take between 7 to 10 days via rail. That same shipment will take only 4-5 days by truck, even faster (2-3 days) if team service is used. Truck has a decided advantage over Rail for time sensitive shipments and on movements of perishable goods. Since truck is faster, the integrity of the movement will be better as well. Less opportunity for shrinkage or damage than rail. Rail can’t compete with truck for short hauls of less than 500 miles. Truck can’t compete with Rail for bulk goods and long-haul freight that is not time or travel sensitive. There is an alternative in the middle. It’s called intermodal, and simply put, it takes advantage of the best of both modes.

Intermodal

A truck picks up the load, it then goes to a rail yard and the contents (usually a container) are then loaded onto a rail flatcar designed for this purpose and moved close (as close as possible) to the destination, where the contents are then put on a truck for final delivery. One key factor is how close the rail pickup and delivery sites are to the actual shipping locations. The closer the more competitive intermodal becomes to truck.  This mode is perfect if you want to move product faster than normal rail, since intermodal trains are typically setup to run thru the system faster, and if you want overall costs lower than pure truckload. Intermodal looks like trucking to the shipper and to the receiver but utilizes the advantages of rail for the largest segments of the movement. One caution with intermodal is that you can’t stop an intermodal shipment while it is on the rail. So, if you change your mind or need to re-reroute it, you usually can’t do that until it completes the rail segment of the journey. With truck you don’t have that issue, it can be re-routed or stopped at any time.

Air Freight

The last mode available is AIR freight. Air freight is the most expensive mode; however, it is also the fastest mode from point A to B when the distance is over 500 miles. If time is the enemy for your freight, then air freight makes sense. Usually, products that are most conducive to air freight are high value, time sensitive products that must be at the destination as quickly as possible. Think computer parts as an example. Air freight movements are not usually large either. Typically, one to three pallets.

Mode Mix

When considering your mode mix you are basically balancing time and place utility against cost. When comparing modes make sure you look at total cost, which includes cash cycles due to terms of payment. Truckers are more lenient than railroads for example. Also look at damage and loss factors, inventory requirements, reliability, and flexibility.

Parcel Ground vs LTL vs Truckload

I will now take a deeper dive and compare Parcel Ground vs LTL vs Truckload. There are some key considerations to make in these evaluations. Ground parcel has what’s known as hundred weight programs for shipping amounts over 150 lbs. These programs make a competitive run at pure Less than Truckload shipments in the 200 to 500 lbs. range. After that, LTL usually is cheaper and a better choice. At the same time, LTL has what’s known as volume rates for shipments over 6 pallets that allows them to try and compete with truckload when the shipment size goes above 10 pallets. In most cases, if you are shipping over 12-13 pallets you are better off cost-wise to use truckload service. There will always be exceptions to the above, so use these as general guidelines only. However, it is important that you explore your options and use those options that provide the best fit to your shipping needs.

How a Third-Party Logistics Company (3PL) can help.

One alternative to making your own selections is to let a 3PL, like Riverside Logistics, handle your shipping needs. They have the tools and experience necessary to make optimum routing and mode selections for any client. Their Transportation Management Software allows for efficient and effective routing applying cost and service parameters geared specifically towards your business model. If you would like more information regarding what Riverside can do for you, please call us at 888-999-0734 and a Logistics Management Consultant will be happy to assist you.

by

What Supply Chain Problems should you be planning for in 2023?

Here’s my list of the top 5, the no-fail 5 for Logistics

  1. Rate increases- you can bet that in 2022 rates will continue rising. These (freight rates) however have already shown tapering in May of 2022. Will it continue or is it just a lull in the action? Base rates have reached a level that is just not sustainable in the long term. My advice is to send out RFP’s and RFQ’s in late third quarter or early fourth quarter  to take effect in the first quarter of 2023. Keep a close eye on the drivers for rates, labor cost, equipment cost, fuel costs and borrowing costs. As these stabilize and maybe even start to recede, it will be time to initiate the requests. You should try to avoid the spot market by signing long term contracts that lock in your rates for at least a year. This way you can predictably plan for your logistics cost for the whole year.
  2. Capacity- Trucks have been tight all year. We are starting to see some improvement in the last 30 days. Will it continue? Probably, but do you really want to run your business on a maybe? Capacity will ease in 2023 especially if a recession hits. However, don’t you think that it’s best for you to do something to ensure an adequate supply of trucks or railcars or intermodal containers, to keep the business running? If capacity loosens up, your access to it will improve. But you are still at the mercy of a significant event. A pandemic, a war, a recession. Your best strategy in 2023 should be to partner with someone who can guarantee a steady supply of quality transportation assets. If you are a smaller business, with 100 million dollars or less in revenue, then you should take a hard look at partnering with a third-party logistics company (3PL) to protect your access to capacity.
  3. Service Levels- in addition to higher rates and less trucks, we have seen a serious erosion in service levels over the last 12 months. This is due to several factors. A primary cause in the LTL markets was their inability to attract and maintain labor pools necessary to handle freight at their terminals. On the truckload side, drivers were quitting or retiring in record numbers and that left it hard to find and run trucks. The entire logistics network went out of kilter. This caused severe backups at ports, terminals, warehouses, and manufacturing sites. It can be described as a domino effect. When one piece of the supply chain puzzle defaults, it affects other pieces, which in turn affect others and so forth and so on. If you want or need to improve your service levels, without risking cost inflation, I suggest that you consider partnering with a 3PL who can help find both adequate and reliable transportation for your goods.
  4. Inventories- with all the recent out of stocks (OOS), companies have increased their inventory levels significantly. With inflationary pressures and a possible recession looming, it may make sense for you to anticipate needing a lot less inventory to run your business in 2023. Pay particular attention to the carrying cost of your inventory and the turns associated with it. You need to carefully manage it in 2022 and develop a plan to be able to reduce it in 2023 if a recession hits. Inventory is idle cash. If sales volumes go down, that means more inventory related cash is tied up in inventory and is not helping the business.
  5. Customer expectations- your customers, like you, are weary of the pandemic related supply chain issues. Just like your ability to serve them has degraded, so has their ability to serve their end users. All in all, expectations have come down to earth, hard and fast. Currently, when you explain that a shipment or order won’t be getting to your customer as fast as they would like, its easier now for them to understand. This condition will change, more than likely it will happen faster than you think and require major adjustments to how you go to market. Be prepared to change your service model metrics. By change, in 2023, this will require much more stringent on-time delivery performance, less out of stock situations, and probably lower costs.

Right now, understanding the supply chain in 2023 is a crapshoot. Sitting back and taking a wait and see approach will not help. You must plan for what you think will happen, as well as, at the same time bullet-proofing your logistics network as much as possible. One key facet to this process should be taking a hard look at using a 3PL to enhance your logistics network.

Riverside Logistics is a 3PL with 25+ years of experience in warehousing and logistics. We have both the experience and know-how to help you “bullet-proof” your logistics network. We would love to have an opportunity to discuss this with you. We can be reached at 888-999-0734. One of our Logistics Management Consultants would be happy to help you.

by

How would a strike at the West Coast ports impact us in 2022?

A potential strike at the West Coast ports  appeared imminent on July 1st but was averted,  for now.   The West Coast ILWU, International Longshore, and Warehouse Union had a contract up for renewal (July 1, 2022). They argued that since the Steamship lines have raised their rates significantly, and the port operators have made exceptional profits, that they should also share in the profits.  Not unreasonable.  Fortunately, as of this writing, it looks like an agreement was reached.

But what if the strike had happened? Below is a likely scenario….

First, the west coast would back up until long after the strike. Second, the east coast would get overloaded, very quickly, either due to sympathy work slowdowns or significantly increased workloads that exceed the east coasts port’s ability to unload and process containers. It would be a mess. As shippers re-route or diverted their shipments to the East Coast to compensate for the strike, the East Coast logistics networks would suffer. Instead of traffic coming from the west to east, those lanes would shut down. The capacity in the west would have less freight flowing back to the east coast so there would be a general lack of trucks to handle long haul freight, in either direction. The trucking network would be negatively impacted and take a long time to sort out. Intermodal movements would suffer as well. This would impact drayage carriers, produce container shortages and result in higher rates.

To summarize, everybody would suffer if the strike had happened, whether or not you ship internationally. The logistics network would be  out of balance, so costs would rise, service levels would drop, and every shipper would be miserable. Remember that it’s a network, with lots of moving pieces. When these pieces don’t move like they’ve been designed to, the network starts to fail. That failure is painful to everyone.

If the Federal Government had stepped in it would have tried to avert the strike. If that happened, then there would still be consequences. The West Coast ILWU could show their ire through work stoppages, slowdowns, sick calls, and any number of methods to slow the flow and impact as many people as possible to demonstrate their worth and power.

What should you do as a shipper to prepare? Here are 3 recommendations to try and protect your margins and maintain your logistics costs at a reasonable/workable level:

  1. Try partnering with a 3PL to lock in rates and services. 3PL’s have multiple contracts with carriers and these can help you manage your costs and protect your service. If you’re a medium to small sized shipper, this type of relationship can really help you.
  2. Pool your resources. Try to concentrate your business into larger pools of freight and sign annual contracts to lock in rates for at least a year. Don’t play the spot markets. You’ll lose in the long run.
  3. Have a plan. Determine what you will do if a strike happens, and you still have trouble shipping to customers. Be transparent with your customers. Make sure that they know what you’re experiencing, what you’re doing about it, and set reasonable expectations with those customers so they can plan accordingly. Make sure you re-visit your plan periodically and adjust it as the picture changes.

It’s not a good time right now for the logistics community. There are several potentially bad environmental factors hitting all at the same time. However, if you plan, partner with a 3PL (a good one) and pool your resources, you stand a much better chance of maintaining your relative competitive position in the marketplace.

Fortunately, a west coast port strike was averted.  But risks still exist in the supply chain.  The government can’t afford to let that happen, neither can the steamship lines or the port operators. A strike was either delayed or pushed off. However, can you afford to sit back and do nothing? It would be wise to discuss and plan for potential disruptions in your supply chain. Hopefully, you’ve weathered the Pandemic related supply chain woes and now this next potential disruption is no longer imminent. At the very least, if you are a small to mid-sized firm, try exploring the possibility of partnering with a 3PL to can help you navigate these tricky logistical waters. There isn’t any downside risk to looking into a 3PL partnership, and there’s a lot of help to be had by doing so.

Riverside Logistics would be happy to help you plan your logistics network, bulletproof your carrier base, and keep you competitive in the marketplace by providing cost effective solutions to your warehousing and transportation needs. After living through the pandemic and the effect it has had on your supply chain, you understand how fragile the network is and how impactful changes to it can be. Don’t be a victim of your supply chain without at least looking into a 3PL relationship. We are here to help and would be very willing to consult with you on potential opportunities to shore-up your network.

Riverside Logistics can be reached at 804-474-7000 Option 4. Ask for a LMC consultant and get started on being proactive towards your supply chain.

by

How does the price of a barrel of oil affect your freight cost?

Freight Rates have been going up at a record pace lately and one of the main reasons is that fuel prices are also at record levels.

In March, U.S. oil spiked to a 13 year high at over $130/barrel. A key driver was the Russian Invasion of Ukraine. In addition, US producers were slow to respond. They just didn’t have the capacity or willingness to ramp up quickly. Right now, demand is high, and supply is constrained, so that means the upward pressure on prices will continue.

When looking at how fuel relates to oil, it’s helpful to understand that refineries produce about 11 gallons of diesel fuel for every 42 gallons of crude oil, so the higher the cost of a barrel of oil, the higher the pump price for diesel. Diesel is the primary source of fuel for large tractor trailers and accounts for approximately 20% of a carriers cost to operate, so it’s going to highly impact trucking related freight rates. This will also take capacity out of the market as independent truckers adjust record high diesel prices. Now  let’s look at different types of loads and transportation methods and how high diesel prices will change your freight cost.

Trucking Types:

Linehaul rates, the base rates for moving product from point A to point B, are triggered primarily by supply and demand factors. Load to Truck ratios drive spot pricing (daily pricing on freight load boards). The more loads and less capacity the higher the linehaul rates. Fuel Surcharges, on the other hand, are usually setup as a sliding scale, based on the Department of Energy ( D.O.E.) national average price of fuel. The scale slides up and down in cents per mile or as a % of revenue in accordance with designated bands of fuel costs. Usually, these fuel surcharges (FSC’s) are in cents per mile for over-the-road truckers, and in % of revenue for Less-than-truckload and Small Package. Current FSC’s are running around 31% for LTL and 96 cents per mile for truckload with diesel at 5.51$/gallon. They have increased dramatically since the first of the year.

The same dynamic between oil costs and fuel costs impact the other modes of transport as well. Ocean, Rail and Air transport all have significant expenses tied to fuel costs.

Ocean

For Ocean, fuel costs represent 50-60% of their operating costs.

Air

For Air carriers it’s more like 40% and is their biggest variable expense. This expense affects air transport belly freight as well as parcel express freight.

Rail

For railroads fuel cost represent about 20% of their operating costs. When fuel prices rise, rail becomes a more desirable solution vs truck, the converse is true when oil and fuel prices drop.

What is being done about all this?

The Carrier community is doing a couple of things.

Air carriers buy fuel hedges to guard against upward price swings. However, when prices drop, margins get hurt. They pass along fuel costs in the form of surcharges on their rates. These are currently running in the neighborhood of 25% of linehaul costs.

Ocean carriers are doing what’s called “slow steaming” to mitigate fuel costs. By reducing their speeds, they can save up to 59% of their fuel costs. The downside is that the travel time increases significantly. From days to weeks in some cases. Ocean carriers charge what’s called a “Bunker Adjustment Factor” or BAF, which is usually tied to the cost of Brent Crude Oil. Currently these charges run by trade lane and are reaching all-time highs of over $600 per 40’ container.

Rail Carriers are running diesel-electric locomotives which capitalize on the benefits of both energy types to improve the efficiency of their travel costs. Railroads, however, also impose mileage-based fuel surcharges. These have doubled since the beginning of 2022. They are now around 76 cents per mile.

The EIA or US Energy Information Administration posts the national average diesel price every Monday. Using this number along with the MPG of a truck (usually around 6mpg) and a pre-determined baseline (typically $1.50/gallon) you can calculate the Fuel surcharges that a motor carrier would ask for. The surcharge scale used is open to negotiation with shippers. Many shippers create their own fuel surcharge tables and when contracting with carriers, may force the carriers to use them. At the end of the day, Line haul cost + fuel surcharges = the total cost of transportation. So, if the shipper has a shipper-favorable fuel surcharge table, then probably the line haul rates will be increased by the carrier to compensate. At the end of the day the carriers must try and protect their margins and recoup their costs.

Depending on what type of shipper you are, a lot of the fuel impact depends on your base rates and whether you buy transportation on a “spot” or a “contractual” basis. If you buy contractually, which is recommended, your base rates usually remain the same for the term of your contract. Most contracts are a for at least one year. If you buy your transportation on the spot market, then you are exposed to the vagaries of the market. Fuel cost is always a floating cost that traditionally moves with the price of oil. Linehaul Base rates float on the spot market based on supply and demand in each market. If there are more loads than trucks, then rates go up. If the converse is true, then rates go down. Just remember if your base prices go up, and fuel is reflected as a percentage of base rates, then you take a larger hit than you would if the base rates didn’t float, i.e.., if you had contractual linehaul rates that were stable for a period. Not only will this save you money, but it will also allow you to plan you costs better.

The goal of any shipper is to negotiate a fuel surcharge that is favorable to their business and helps them maintain a strong competitive position. There are a few items that shippers should consider when deciding on a carrier to ship their goods.

  • Make sure the carrier fully explains how their fuel surcharge formula works and when it is adjusted. For example, weekly, monthly, quarterly, every Tuesday, etc.
  • Don’t assume that a high fuel scale base rate is bad. When the base fuel rate is higher, fuel surcharges usually are lower. Also make sure your cost bands are as large as possible. This will help minimize fluctuations.
  • If you negotiate a favorable FSC scale, make sure that your base linehaul rates are fixed for at least a year. This way your base doesn’t change except when it’s time to re-negotiate the contract. Thus, allowing you to better plan your costs for the year.
  • Make sure that when comparing carriers and modes that you fully understand how their individual fsc’s apply. Also, don’t forget to calculate the transit implication of using one mode over another. Dollars saved on transport can be lost because the products don’t arrive as soon as they are needed.

What does all of this mean for your freight cost in the next year? Lot’s of uncertainty and increasing complexity of solutions that provide a secure supply chain at a market price that allows your business to compete and grow. With all of this uncertainty, small & mid-size companies are going to find it challenging to mitigate cost and remain competitive.

Riverside Logistics is an expert in logistics costs and can help you with fuel surcharge negotiations and setting up scales favorable to your business. Give us a call at 804-474-7700 extension 82. We are here to help!

 

News & Events

Read Other News & Events

Case Studies

Read More Case Studies

SMC3
Transportation Intermediaries Association
Small, Women, and Minority Owned Business
Worlds Greatest Logistics Company